As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Links marked “Affiliate link” may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
The BGMG set has the longest span, at 24 inches, and a stated 50 pound rating with toggle bolts for drywall. The Solid Walnut set also states 50 pounds, in a shorter 16.5-inch size. By listed floor footprint, Fixwal 3+1 Tier Bathroom Floating Shelves is the smallest (0.65 sq ft) and BGMG Wood Floating Shelves for Wall the largest (1.12 sq ft). Specifications come from Amazon listing data checked October 3, 2026; we have not tested these products. Confirm the selected variant on Amazon before ordering.
Quick compare: the products in this guide
Sizes come from the Amazon listings as we read them; check the product page for the current details before you buy.
| Product | Listed details | Link |
|---|---|---|
| BGMG Wood Floating Shelves for Wall 24 inch Set of 2, Rustic Wooden Wall… | 6.7″D x 24″W x 1.25″H | See details on Amazon Affiliate link |
| Fixwal 3+1 Tier Bathroom Floating Shelves Over Toilet, Dark Brown | 15.8″D x 5.9″W x 0.6″H | See details on Amazon Affiliate link |
| Solid Walnut Floating Shelves for Wall 16.5 Inch Set of 2, Round Edge Wall… | 16.5″D x 6″W x 1″H | See details on Amazon Affiliate link |
Three options at a glance
| Pick | Listed dimensions | Floor footprint | Footprint rank |
|---|---|---|---|
| BGMG Wood Floating Shelves for Wall | 6.7″ D × 24″ W × 1.25″ H | 160.8 sq in (1.12 sq ft) | Largest |
| Fixwal 3+1 Tier Bathroom Floating Shelves | 15.8″ D × 5.9″ W × 0.6″ H | 93.22 sq in (0.65 sq ft) | Smallest |
| Solid Walnut Floating Shelves for Wall | 16.5″ D × 6″ W × 1″ H | 99 sq in (0.69 sq ft) | Middle |
1. BGMG Wood Floating Shelves for Wall 24 inch Set of 2, Rustic Wooden Wall Mount Shelves for Bathroom Living Room Bedroom Kitchen Farmhouse -24×6.7-Dark Walnut — Largest listed footprint
Listed details: dimensions 6.7″ D × 24″ W × 1.25″ H; item weight 6.4 pounds; material Pine; color Dark Walnut.
The BGMG set has two shelves, each listed at 6.7 inches deep by 24 inches wide by 1.25 inches thick, or 1.12 sq ft, the largest footprint of the three. The listing states real pine in a dark walnut stain, a Country Rustic and Farmhouse style name, and an item weight of 6.4 pounds. It states the shelves hold up to 50 pounds using brackets designed for American wall studs. The package includes stainless steel galvanized invisible brackets, toggle bolts for drywall and step-by-step instructions. The listing suggests uses in the kitchen for spices and cups, and in the bathroom. It does not mention moisture resistance.
Pros
- States a capacity of up to 50 pounds, with invisible stainless steel galvanized brackets.
- Toggle bolts for drywall and step-by-step instructions are listed in the package.
- Longest span at 24 inches and 1.25 inches thick, in real pine with a dark walnut stain.
Cons
- The listing text does not mention moisture resistance, which matters for a bathroom.
- The 50 pound figure is tied to brackets designed for American wall studs, and the listing does not say what the drywall toggle bolts carry on their own.
- Largest footprint at 1.12 sq ft per shelf, and each is 24 inches wide, so it needs more wall width than the 16.5 and 15.8 inch options.
Who it is for / who should skip it: Best for a bathroom wall with room for a 24 inch run and a stud to hit, where a stated 50 pound rating matters. Skip it if the wall is narrow or you want something over a toilet.
2. Fixwal 3+1 Tier Bathroom Floating Shelves Over Toilet, Dark Brown — Smallest listed footprint
Listed details: dimensions 15.8″ D × 5.9″ W × 0.6″ H; item weight 16 ounces; material Wood; color Dark Brown.
The Fixwal set is a 3+1 tier unit with four paulownia boards, each listed at 15.8 inches by 5.9 inches by 0.6 inches, or 0.65 sq ft, the smallest footprint of the three. The listing states a dark brown color, an item weight of 16 ounces, and that two of the boards are connected by leaf-style ironwork to form a 15.8 by 5.9 by 5.9 inch space. The package is stated to include 4 metal brackets, 2 leaf-style ironworks and 12 plastic anchors, plus an installation manual. The title says it is meant to go over a toilet. The listing text does not state a weight capacity.
Pros
- Four boards in a 3+1 layout, with a 15.8 by 5.9 by 5.9 inch space formed by two boards and ironwork.
- The title is aimed at over-the-toilet use, which the other two listings do not claim.
- An installation manual, 4 metal brackets and 12 plastic anchors are listed in the package.
Cons
- No weight capacity is stated in the listing text.
- Boards are only 0.6 inches thick, the thinnest of the three (the others are 1.25 and 1 inch).
- Each board is 5.9 inches deep, so larger items will not fit, and the listed hardware is plastic anchors, so the wall type matters.
Who it is for / who should skip it: Pick it for light items above a toilet where the extra boards help sort things. Skip it if you want to hold books or heavy jars, since no rating is given.
3. Solid Walnut Floating Shelves for Wall 16.5 Inch Set of 2, Round Edge Wall Mounted Shelf,Rustic Farmhouse Wooden Floating Shelf,Wood Wall Shelf for Bathroom Living Room,Bedroom,Kitchen — Middle listed footprint
Listed details: dimensions 16.5″ D × 6″ W × 1″ H; item weight 16 ounces; material Solid Walnut wood; color Dark Walnut.
The Solid Walnut set has two shelves, each listed at 16.5 inches by 6 inches by 1 inch, or 0.69 sq ft, the middle footprint. The spec table lists solid walnut, a dark walnut color, a Modern and Rustic style name and an item weight of 16 ounces. The bullets describe softly rounded edges, a hidden steel bracket and a stated capacity of up to 50 lbs, suited to hardcover books and kitchen essentials. The title calls it a Rustic Farmhouse set with a round edge. The listing text does not say what hardware is included or whether the finish suits damp rooms.
Pros
- States up to 50 lbs, the same figure as the BGMG, in a shorter 16.5 inch size.
- Solid walnut with a hidden steel bracket and softly rounded edges.
- 1 inch thick boards, thicker than the Fixwal’s 0.6 inches.
Cons
- The listing text does not say what mounting hardware or instructions are included.
- No mention of moisture resistance or a protective finish for a bathroom.
- At 16.5 inches long it spans 24 – 16.5 = 7.5 inches less than the BGMG shelves, so it holds fewer items per shelf.
Who it is for / who should skip it: A fit for a smaller bathroom wall where you want solid walnut and a stated 50 lb rating. Skip it if you need a listed hardware kit or a 24 inch run.
What to check before buying dark wood bathroom shelves
Start with moisture and finish. Bathrooms are damp, and none of the listing texts mentions moisture resistance. The BGMG is real pine with a walnut stain, the Fixwal is paulownia wood in dark brown, and the Solid Walnut is solid walnut. Ask the seller about the finish before mounting any of them near a shower.
Second, size and layout. The BGMG shelves are 24 inches wide by 6.7 deep (1.12 sq ft each), the Solid Walnut shelves are 16.5 by 6 (0.69 sq ft) and the Fixwal boards are 15.8 by 5.9 (0.65 sq ft). Only the Fixwal is titled for over the toilet, with a 3+1 layout and a 15.8 by 5.9 by 5.9 inch space between two boards. If wall width is tight, the 16.5 and 15.8 inch options fit better than a 24 inch pair.
Third, weight rating. The BGMG and Solid Walnut listings both state up to 50 pounds. The Fixwal text states no figure, and its boards are 0.6 inches thick against 1.25 and 1 inch. Treat it as light-duty until the seller gives a number.
Fourth, mounting. The BGMG lists invisible brackets, toggle bolts for drywall and instructions, and says its brackets are designed for American wall studs. The Fixwal lists 4 metal brackets, 12 plastic anchors and a manual. The Solid Walnut mentions a hidden steel bracket but the text does not list other hardware. Match the hardware to your wall type.
Fifth, look. All three read dark: dark walnut, dark brown and dark walnut, and the BGMG and Solid Walnut listings both say the wood grain shows.
Worked example: fit math for these three options
This worked example is our own planning arithmetic from the listed dimensions, not test results. The wall length and walkway width are assumed example values; replace them with your measurements.
Wall example. Assume 36 inches of clear wall.
- BGMG Wood Floating Shelves for Wall: 36 − 24 = 12 inches spare; centred, 6 inches on each side before trim, plugs or curtains.
- Fixwal 3+1 Tier Bathroom Floating Shelves: 36 − 5.9 = 30.1 inches spare; centred, 15.05 inches on each side before trim, plugs or curtains.
- Solid Walnut Floating Shelves for Wall: 36 − 6 = 30 inches spare; centred, 15 inches on each side before trim, plugs or curtains.
Walkway example. The US Access Board gives 36 inches as the minimum clear width for an accessible route. That figure is a yardstick, not a rule for private homes. To keep 36 inches clear beside each product, the walkway between it and the opposite obstacle must be at least 36 inches plus its depth:
- BGMG Wood Floating Shelves for Wall: 36 + 6.7 = 42.7 inches of total path width.
- Fixwal 3+1 Tier Bathroom Floating Shelves: 36 + 15.8 = 51.8 inches of total path width.
- Solid Walnut Floating Shelves for Wall: 36 + 16.5 = 52.5 inches of total path width.
Footprint. Depth × width, converted at 144 square inches per square foot:
- BGMG Wood Floating Shelves for Wall: 6.7 × 24 = 160.8 sq in, or 1.12 sq ft.
- Fixwal 3+1 Tier Bathroom Floating Shelves: 15.8 × 5.9 = 93.22 sq in, or 0.65 sq ft.
- Solid Walnut Floating Shelves for Wall: 16.5 × 6 = 99 sq in, or 0.69 sq ft.
Mistakes to avoid
- Assuming a shelf is bathroom-rated. None of the three listing texts mentions moisture resistance. Ask about the finish before you mount one near a shower.
- Reading 50 pounds as a guarantee on any wall. The BGMG ties its figure to brackets designed for American wall studs and also ships toggle bolts for drywall. The listing does not say what each method carries.
- Overlooking board thickness. The Fixwal boards are 0.6 inches thick, against 1.25 inches for the BGMG and 1 inch for the Solid Walnut, and the Fixwal states no weight rating.
- Measuring only depth. The BGMG shelves are 24 inches wide while the Solid Walnut and Fixwal boards are 16.5 and 15.8 inches. Check your wall width, not just the shelf depth of about 6 inches.
Related guides
- best black and white floating shelves
- best floating shelves for a home office
- best monitor stands and desk shelves
Frequently asked questions
How much weight can dark wood bathroom shelves hold?
The BGMG and Solid Walnut listings each state up to 50 pounds. The Fixwal listing text gives no capacity figure. These are the sellers’ numbers, we have not tested any of them, and the BGMG ties its figure to brackets designed for wall studs.
Are these real wood?
Yes, per the listings. The BGMG is described as real pine with a walnut stain, the Fixwal as 100% natural paulownia wood in dark brown, and the Solid Walnut as solid walnut. None of the listing texts says whether the finish resists moisture.
Which one goes over a toilet?
The Fixwal, whose title says over toilet. It has four boards in a 3+1 layout, each 15.8 by 5.9 inches. The BGMG and Solid Walnut titles do not mention over-toilet use, so check the clearance for your own space.
Does mounting hardware come included?
The BGMG lists invisible brackets, toggle bolts for drywall and instructions. The Fixwal lists 4 metal brackets, 12 plastic anchors and an installation manual. The Solid Walnut mentions a hidden steel bracket, and its listing text does not describe other hardware.
Products worth checking
We have not tested these products. Sizes and features come from the Amazon listings as we read them; where a listing does not say, we say so.
BGMG Wood Floating Shelves for Wall 24 inch Set of 2, Rustic Wooden Wall Mount Shelves for Bathroom Living Room Bedroom Kitchen Farmhouse -24×6.7-Dark Walnut
See details on Amazon Affiliate linkFixwal 3+1 Tier Bathroom Floating Shelves Over Toilet, Dark Brown
See details on Amazon Affiliate linkSolid Walnut Floating Shelves for Wall 16.5 Inch Set of 2, Round Edge Wall Mounted Shelf,Rustic Farmhouse Wooden Floating Shelf,Wood Wall Shelf for Bathroom Living Room,Bedroom,Kitchen
See details on Amazon Affiliate linkSources checked
- US Access Board guide to clear width
- Amazon listing for option 1
- Amazon listing for option 2
- Amazon listing for option 3
Specifications come from the Amazon listings as we read them for this guide. Product details and availability can change, so confirm on the product page before you buy.