As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Links marked “Affiliate link” may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.
Choose a wood floating shelf by its listed finish and material, not by its name. None of the four sets below describes solid oak. Of the four floating shelf sets below, the Fun Memories 36 inch set lists “Oak” as its color, the Rustic Brown set has “Oak” in its title but an MDF core with a wood-grain finish, and the two solid pine sets are finished in walnut. The 36 inch length is the longest in this set, and the stated load figures run from 33 lb to 70 lb, depending on which figure is used. Related reading: L-shaped floating shelves and narrow wall shelves.
What the four sets say
Figures come from each product’s Amazon listing. Confirm them on the product page before buying.
| Shelf set | Dimensions (listing) | Material and finish (listing) | Load (listing) | Mounting (listing) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fun Memories Floating Shelves for Wall, 36 in, Set of 2 | 6.5 D x 36 W x 1.5 H in | Engineered wood (CARB P2 and FSC-certified); oak color | 35 lb (spec field) | Iron brackets; rubber stopper design |
| Rustic Brown Floating Shelves for Wall, Oak Small Wall Mounted Floating Shelves, Set of 2 | 11.81 D x 1.5 W x 7.09 H in (spec field); 12, 24 or 36 in lengths (bullet text) | MDF core with PVC finish; rustic brown wood grain | 33 lb (spec field) | Hidden brackets; screws |
| BGMG 36 inch Walnut Floating Shelves for Wall, Set of 2, Solid Real Wood | 6.7 D x 36 W x 1.25 H in | Solid pine with dark walnut stain | 50 lb (spec field); 70 lb (bullet text) | Brackets described in the bullet text |
| Homeforia 36 Inch Floating Shelves, High-End Solid Pine Wood, Set of 2 | 6.5 D x 36 W x 1.75 H in | Solid pine; American walnut satin stain | 50 lb per shelf (bullet text) | Metal bracket hidden inside the shelf |
Product by product
Fun Memories Floating Shelves for Wall, 36 Inch Floating Shelves Set of 2, Hanging Shelf with Invisible Brackets
Affiliate link
- Dimensions: 6.5 inches deep, 36 inches wide, 1.5 inches thick (spec field). The item weighs 5 lb.
- Material: CARB P2 certified engineered wood and FSC-certified engineered wood, with military-grade iron mounting brackets, according to the material field.
- Color: oak. Style: rustic.
- Load: 35 lb maximum (spec field).
- Design: a rubber stopper design that adds friction between the bracket and the shelf, according to the bullet text.
This is the one in the set whose listing names oak as the color. It is engineered wood, not solid oak, so the look is the finish, not the material. Its 35 lb figure is the lowest of the three 36 inch sets that state a load. The Rustic Brown set, which comes in several lengths, lists 33 lb.
Rustic Brown Floating Shelves for Wall, Oak Small Wall Mounted Floating Shelves Set of 2
Affiliate link
- Dimensions: 11.81 inches deep, 1.5 inches wide, 7.09 inches high (spec field). The bullet text describes a 7 inch depth and 1.5 inch thickness, with lengths of 12, 24 and 36 inches.
- Material: a high-density MDF core with a waterproof PVC laminated surface, according to the bullet text.
- Finish: a wood-grain finish in rustic brown.
- Load: 33 lb maximum (spec field).
- Mounting: hidden brackets. The bullet text says to secure the brackets with screws, level them, then slide the shelf on and fasten the two bottom screws.
The title says oak, but the material is MDF with a wood-grain laminate, and the color field says rustic brown. Use this set if you want the shorter lengths or a PVC surface that wipes clean. The spec-field dimensions list depth and height differently from the bullet text, so confirm the size on the product page.
BGMG 36 inch Walnut Floating Shelves for Wall Set of 2, Solid Real Wood Rustic Mount Shelves
Affiliate link
- Dimensions: 6.7 inches deep, 36 inches wide, 1.25 inches high (spec field). The item weighs 6.4 lb.
- Material: solid pine, according to the material field and bullet text.
- Finish: dark walnut, in a rustic style.
- Load: the spec field gives 50 lb maximum. The bullet text says the shelves support up to 70 lb with the brackets described there. The two figures do not match.
This is the only solid wood option in the set. The solid pine is real wood, but its finish is walnut, not oak. Because the load figures conflict, use the lower one until the seller confirms.
Homeforia 36 Inch Floating Shelves, High-End Solid Pine Wood, Set of 2
Affiliate link
- Dimensions: 6.5 inches deep, 36 inches wide, 1.75 inches high (spec field). The item weighs 7.6 lb.
- Material: solid pine, with a metal bracket, according to the material field.
- Finish: American walnut, satin dark tone.
- Load: 50 lb per shelf (bullet text). The spec field gives a minimum weight of 50 lb.
- Mounting: the bullet text says the metal bracket sits inside the shelf body, so no hardware shows. Assembly instructions are included.
This is the thickest shelf in the set at 1.75 inches, which gives it a solid edge. Its load figures agree at 50 lb per shelf. Like the BGMG set, its finish is walnut rather than oak.
Measure the wall and the studs
A 36 inch shelf needs two or more brackets, and the listings do not say how many brackets each set includes beyond the pair. Find the studs in the wall and place the brackets into them where you can. If the wall is plaster or masonry, use a fixing rated for the load. This is general practice, not a figure from any listing. Keep the shelf level by checking with a level before the final screw.
Oak, walnut and pine: what the labels mean
Oak is a color in one listing, a word in another title, and absent from the material fields of all four. Walnut and pine describe the finish and wood of the other two. If solid oak is essential, these listings do not show it, so look for a listing that names solid oak in its material field.
Mistakes to avoid
- Buying a finish by the title alone. One listing has oak in its title and an MDF core.
- Trusting one load figure. The BGMG set gives 50 lb and 70 lb.
- Loading a 36 inch shelf at one point. Spread the weight along the length.
- Mounting without a level. A shelf that is off level shows it on every item.
Who may not need floating shelves
If the wall has room for a cabinet or a bookcase, a floating shelf may not hold as much. A shelf is a good choice for light decor and a few books, not for a full library.
Frequently asked questions
Which set is solid oak?
None of the four listings describes solid oak. The Fun Memories set is listed in an oak color. The two solid pine sets have walnut finishes.
Which shelf is the thickest?
The Homeforia shelf is 1.75 inches thick. The Rustic Brown set is 1.5 inches, the Fun Memories set is 1.5 inches, and the BGMG set is 1.25 inches.
Which set has the highest load?
The Homeforia set lists 50 lb per shelf, and the BGMG set lists 50 lb in its spec field and 70 lb in its bullet text. The Fun Memories set lists 35 lb and the Rustic Brown set lists 33 lb.
Next step
Pick the length and finish you need, check the load and thickness on the product page, and confirm the stud locations before you drill. If solid oak matters, look for a listing that names it in the material field.
