As an Amazon Associate this site earns from qualifying purchases. Every product link in this guide is an Amazon affiliate link. Read the affiliate disclosure for how these links work.
For a dining room wall, the Meangood Rustic Floating Shelves set of two is the shallowest of the three, at 4.7 inches deep, and its listing is the only one that names a dining room use. The Boswillon Floating Shelves set of two in white is 15.72 inches wide and 5.1 inches deep, with a 20 lb maximum. The HuiDao 3-tier solid wood unit has the most shelf space and a 50 lb maximum, but at 17.3 inches wide and 18.9 inches high it is the widest and tallest of the three. If the wall section is narrow, start with Meangood or Boswillon; for more display and storage on one wall, check the HuiDao unit first.
How the three shelves are compared
Each shelf below is judged on the overall size, weight limit, material, color and assembly stated on its Amazon listing, as read on 18 October 2026. Three measures decide most of the choice in a dining room:
- Depth. Depth sets how far items sit off the wall. Meangood is 4.7 inches deep.
- Width. Width sets how much of the wall one shelf covers. The three range from 15.72 inches to 17.3 inches.
- Stated load. Each listing gives a maximum weight: 20 lb for Boswillon, 30 lb for Meangood and 50 lb for HuiDao.
Material and assembly matter too. They decide the finish you see and how much work the wall mounting takes.
Quick compare
| Shelf | Listed size (D x W x H) | Shelves | Material | Color | Listed maximum weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Boswillon Floating Shelves, Set of 2, 16 in | 5.1 x 15.72 x 1.8 in | 2 | Engineered wood | White | 20 lb |
| Meangood Rustic Floating Shelves, Set of 2, 17 in | 4.7 x 16 x 2.3 in | 2 | Metal and wood | Carbonized black | 30 lb |
| HuiDao 100% Solid Wood Wall Shelf, 3-Tier | 5.1 x 17.3 x 18.9 in | 3 | Solid wood | Brown | 50 lb |
The three shelves
Boswillon Floating Shelves, Set of 2, 16 in, White
- Listed size: 5.1 in deep, 15.72 in wide, 1.8 in high
- Pack: set of 2 shelves
- Material: engineered wood
- Color: white
- Listed maximum weight: 20 lb. The bullets say the shelves hold up to 20 lb of art pieces.
- Stated feature: a front lip that the listing says protects items from slipping or falling off
- Mounting: the listing describes wall mounting as simple
Limits. The 20 lb figure is the lowest of the three, and the listing does not say whether it applies to each shelf or to the pair. The shelf is engineered wood, not solid wood. The bullets name books, plants, picture frames and art pieces as uses; they do not name a dining room.
Meangood Rustic Floating Shelves for Wall, 17 inch Bathroom Shelf, Set of 2
- Listed size: 4.7 in deep, 16 in wide, 2.3 in high
- Pack: set of 2 shelves
- Material: metal and wood. The bullets describe real solid wood with metal brackets.
- Color: carbonized black
- Listed maximum weight: 30 lb
- Item weight: 16 ounces as listed
- Assembly: the listing says assembly is required and that all necessary hardware is included
- Stated uses: the listing names a bathroom, a kitchen and the dining room
Limits. The listing does not say whether the 30 lb maximum applies to each shelf or to the pair. Its uses cover bathroom, kitchen and dining room, so the dining room is one of several uses rather than the main one. At 4.7 inches deep it holds less depth than the other two, which suits a narrow wall but leaves less room for deeper items.
100% Solid Wood Wall Shelf 3-Tier, Rustic Floating Shelves Wall Mounted Storage Rack, Farmhouse Decor Hanging Shelf Display Shelves
- Listed size: 5.1 in deep, 17.3 in wide, 18.9 in high
- Shelves: 3 tiers
- Material: solid wood, per the title and bullets
- Color: brown
- Listed maximum weight: 50 lb
- Bracket shape: wavy edge, as listed
- Assembly: the listing says assembly is included
- Stated uses: living rooms, bedrooms, kitchens and bathrooms, with books, plants, mugs and decor named as items
Limits. The listing does not say whether the 50 lb maximum is the total for the unit or the load for each tier. It is the widest and tallest of the three, so it covers more wall. The text read does not name a dining room.
The size arithmetic
The depth and width figures come from the listings. The shelf surface numbers below are our own arithmetic from those figures. They assume each shelf spans the full listed width and depth, so treat them as estimates rather than listed specifications.
- Meangood: 4.7 x 16 = 75.2 sq in per shelf. Two shelves = 150.4 sq in.
- Boswillon: 5.1 x 15.72 = 80.2 sq in per shelf (rounded). Two shelves = 160.3 sq in.
- HuiDao: 5.1 x 17.3 = 88.2 sq in per shelf (rounded). Three shelves = 264.7 sq in.
Depth gap: 5.1 – 4.7 = 0.4 in, so Meangood is 0.4 inch shallower than the other two. Width gap: 16 – 15.72 = 0.28 in, so Meangood is 0.28 inch wider than Boswillon. HuiDao is 17.3 – 16 = 1.3 in wider than Meangood.
Which one to choose
- Narrow wall section, shallow shelf: Meangood. It is the shallowest at 4.7 in, and its listing names a dining room use.
- Narrow pair with a front lip: Boswillon. It is 15.72 in wide and 5.1 in deep, but its 20 lb maximum is the lowest of the three.
- More display on one wall: HuiDao. It gives 264.7 sq in of estimated shelf surface across three tiers and a 50 lb maximum.
Before hanging anything heavy, compare the weight you plan to store with the maximum in the listing and check the mounting hardware that comes with the product you choose. For more options, see the narrow wall shelf and L-shaped floating shelves guides.
Frequently asked questions
Does any of these shelves name a dining room?
Yes, the Meangood listing says the shelf can be used in the dining room, alongside bathroom and kitchen use. The Boswillon and HuiDao listings, as read, do not name a dining room.
Which shelf holds the most weight?
The HuiDao 3-tier unit, with a 50 lb maximum listed. Meangood lists 30 lb and Boswillon lists 20 lb. Neither the Boswillon nor the HuiDao listing says whether its figure is per shelf or for the whole unit.
Which shelf is the shallowest?
Meangood, at 4.7 inches deep. Boswillon and HuiDao are 5.1 inches deep.
Links in this guide are Amazon affiliate links.
